Update: I was wrong about house rules ruining games
My friend Dana came over last Friday and we played Catan with her family's weird rule where you can trade resource cards at a 3 to 1 rate no matter what. I had been telling people for months that house rules just make games messy and unfair. But watching her 9 year old actually stay in the game and have fun made me rethink my whole stance. Turns out some tweaks keep casual players at the table instead of getting crushed early. Does anyone have a house rule they used to hate but now swear by?
A 3 to 1 trade no matter what is just handing out free stuff and it throws off the whole balance of the game for everyone else. Sure the kid had fun, but did the adults actually get a real game or did they just let her win with extra help? One fun night does not mean the rule is good, it means the kid got bored of losing and they bent everything to fix it.