Warning: my game group in Denver shamed me out of sleeving every card and they were right
For two years I put every single card in my collection into sleeves. Even the cheap party games. My buddy Dave at our Tuesday night group in Denver kept telling me I was wasting money and time on games I'd play maybe three times. I blew him off. Then I did the math on my shelf: 41 games, about $180 in sleeves, and half those games had never hit the table more than twice. Now I only sleeve the ones that get shuffled hard, like my deck builders. Dave gets to say he told me so at the next game night. How do you all decide which games earn sleeves?