I've been binding for about 5 years now, mostly in my garage in Austin. Every forum and YouTube video swore by PVA for everything. I figured starch paste was just for snobs who liked stirring pots. Then last month I grabbed a 1920s manual from a library sale for 3 dollars. It had a whole chapter on why old bindings still hold up, all about paste flexibility. I tried a batch on a rebind of a 1940s novel that kept cracking at the hinges. After 2 weeks of daily opening and closing, not a single crease. The paste let the spine move in a way PVA never did. I'm not tossing my PVA entirely, but I'm wondering how many other old-school materials I've been ignoring. Has anyone else had a similar flip after trying a traditional recipe?
Boy, I have to push back on this one. Two weeks of opening a book is nothing, that is not a real test, so of course nothing cracked yet. PVA gets a bad rap because people slather it on thick and glue the whole spine solid, then act surprised when it snaps. Used right, in thin layers and kept out of the joint area, PVA holds fine for decades and it does not attract bugs or mold the way a wet starch paste can if your garage gets humid like mine does in July. And let's be honest, how many of those crusty old paste bindings from the 1920s are still around in good shape? The ones that survived did so because somebody stored them right, not because the paste was magic. That three dollar book sold you a story as much as a method, and now you are ready to toss five years of what actually worked for you.