Tried a vintage hand plane on some oak last week and it was a mess

Picked up an old Stanley No. 5 at a yard sale for $20, thinking it would be a fun throwback. After a full afternoon of trying to get a clean shaving, I just got tear-out and frustration. I learned that the sole was way out of flat, something I didn't even think to check on an old tool. Anyone know a good shop in the Tacoma area that can re-surface a plane like that?

3 comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log In

3 Comments

mason_craig346mo ago

You're blaming the tool but it's probably your technique. Vintage planes work fine with a sharp iron and proper setup. People used them for decades without machine shops. A warped sole can often be worked around by adjusting the chipbreaker and taking lighter cuts. Spending money to flatten it seems like a waste when you could just practice more.

9

robert_roberts6mo ago

My grandpa's old plane was warped and he just made it work.

4

gavinw536mo ago

Honestly, that "make it work" attitude is how we ended up with so much amazing old furniture (and knowledge).

9