The old finisher in Tulsa swore by a magnesium float on everything and it cost me a slab
Back when I was green, a finisher with 30 years in the trade out of Tulsa gave me one piece of advice: just run a magnesium float over the whole thing and skip the steel trowel, no need for all that extra work. I took it as gospel because he had been doing it longer than I had been alive. Fast forward to a 900 square foot shop floor pour for a customer in Broken Arrow, and I followed his advice to the letter. What I got was a surface with more fuzz and drag than a gym floor, and the customer ran a hand across it and asked why it felt like a sidewalk. I had to come back the next weekend and burnish the daylights out of it, lost a whole Saturday, and the guy docked me $300 for the delay. The lesson for me was that a float opens the surface and closes nothing, and if the spec calls for a hard trowel finish, you trowel. Has anyone else had an old timer hand them a shortcut that turned into a callback?
Tulsa wisdom strikes again, huh? Sounds like that 30-year finisher was really just a 30-year talker. A magnesium float doing the job of a steel trowel is like using a rake to mop a floor: it touches the surface but fixes nothing. Your guy had you open that slab up like a sponge and then act shocked when it felt like a sidewalk. Next time a vet hands you a shortcut, ask him to sign a paper saying he will come fix it on his Saturday.