Update: Saw how the film handled a key family dinner moment

In the movie adaptation, the big family argument at dinner was much quieter. The novel had everyone shouting and interrupting, which showed their tension better. I felt the screen version smoothed things over too much. That's why I like the original story's version more for its raw feel.

3 comments

3 Comments

the_jake2mo ago

The 2005 Pride & Prejudice movie did the same thing with the first dinner at Netherfield. The book has this awkward, chaotic mess where everyone is talking over each other and it's painfully funny. The film makes it so much more polite and quiet. The book version just had so much more MEANING because you felt the real, tense social mess happening.

mary_kelly2mo ago

Real fights are messier than movie ones.

rivere522mo ago

Yeah, that's such a good way to put it. Have you ever noticed how movie fights, or even big family arguments on screen, always have this clear back-and-forth? In real life, people are all talking at once, someone brings up something from six years ago, and it just spirals into this weird, loud mess where no one is really listening.